Restrictions in the Workplace
Employer can restrict the private use of internet and/or social media during working hours over the workplace internet. The employer may limit the internet provided by the workplace to be used for business purposes, as well as block access to social media sites and/or certain sites.
Can the employer monitor, access, review the employee’s electronic communications?
Employer’s legitimate interest is essential for the surveillance of employee communication. Legitimate interest is assessed for each individual case by taking into account the characteristics of the workplace and the job the employee performs. In the Constitutional Court’s decision no. 2018/31036, as the purpose of the e-mail surveillance was to ensure the business to run effectively in the workplace which provides financial services with a large number of employees, legitimate interest of the employer was recognised. In this regard, the Personal Data Protection Board has issued several decisions imposing administrative fines in cases where the employer has monitored employees using tools without fulfilling the obligation to inform. The Board examines such cases within the framework of the six criteria established by the Constitutional Court under this heading. The same approach was also adopted in Constitutional Court’s decision no. 2016/13010, and although the surveillance was found lawful as the employee was not informed beforehand, the legitimate interest of the employer was recognised in surveillance of employee communication in order to ensure effective conduct of business. It is crucial, however, that this surveillance of employee communication is conducted with the employee’s knowledge. Even when the legal basis for surveillance is legitimate interest, the employer’s obligation to inform under the DP Law remains. In this regard, the Supreme Court holds that even though a confidentiality agreement may stipulate that the employee is prohibited from taking company information and documents outside the workplace, either verbally or in writing, and even if the employee violates this obligation, it is considered unlawful for the employer to monitor the employee using a program installed on the employee’s computer without their knowledge. Consequently, the Supreme Court deems the termination of the employee’s contract, based on evidence obtained in this manner, to be unlawful. In this regard, it would be fair to state that employers have a legitimate interest in monitoring email conversations during internal investigations or inspections to ensure that business is conducted effectively and that laws and regulations as well as company policies are followed. As a personal data processing activity, the employer must base its processing on one of the conditions under Article 5 of the DP Law as well as comply with the principles under Article 4. In case the employer bases its processing on the legal basis of legitimate interest, a balance test should be conducted with the legitimate interest of the employer as data controller and the fundamental rights of the employee as data subject. In order to process data based on this condition, the data controller must have a legitimate interest and the fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject must not be damaged. In practice, particularly in internal investigation processes, it is common for global companies to have these investigations conducted not by the employer, but by the global entities to which the employer is affiliated. In such cases, the internal investigation process cannot be justified based on the legitimate interest of the employer as a data controller. If an internal investigation is conducted by a third party other than the employer, explicit consent must be obtained from the employees.
Such a sharing by the employee, in any case, concerns the disclosure of confidential information and personal rights if it directly targets an employee. In accordance with Article 25/II-b of the Employment Law, the employer can immediately terminate the employment agreement without having to pay severance, whether it is an agreement for definite or an indefinite period, before it expires or without having to comply with the notice periods, if the employee speaks or acts against the honour or reputation of the employer or a member of the employer’s family, or asserts or accuses the employer in matters affecting his honour with groundless accusations. Therefore, use of social media to disparage the employer can be a reason for immediate termination of the employment relation, if the employer duly finds out about such social media post before the employee deletes it. Also, divulging confidential information is also regarded as a reason for immediate termination. Therefore, using social media for this purpose would also be result in employment relation. The employer, as a data controller, may need to monitor employees’ social media activities to prevent the unauthorised sharing of personal data processed within the organisation. This responsibility requires taking technical and administrative measures to protect such data. For instance, The Personal Data Protection Board’s dated 2022 and numbered 2022/630 highlighted a case where a doctor shared patient photos on social media without consent. The hospital, aware of this, failed to prevent it, leading to a 100,000 TRY fine for not taking the necessary precautions.