Dismissal indemnity: the six-month salary cap is removed for employees hired before 7 March 2015 by small companies
The Constitutional Court has once again ruled on the system of safeguards against unlawful dismissal, eliminating – through Judgment no. 174/2026, filed on 22 October 2026 – a disparity in treatment affecting employees hired before 7 March 2015 by small companies with up to 15 employees in total in the whole Italian territory.
The issue concerned Article 8 of Law no. 604/1966, which, for employers with more than 15 employees and up to 60 employees (to be considered in total, in the whole Italian territory, and not per individual production unit, unlike the provisions of Article 18 of the Workers’ Statute ), allowed the labour court to raise the ceiling of the indemnity for unlawful dismissal to up to 10 months’ pay for employees with more than 10 years’ service, and up to 14 months’ pay for those with more than 20 years’ service. This option was, however, not available to employees of employers which did not exceed the overall employment threshold of 15 employees in the whole Italian territory.
The Constitutional Court declared the said Article 8 to be unconstitutional in so far as it contains the words “if employed by an employer who employs more than fifteen employees”, thereby extending the entitlement to the said increase to individuals employed by companies with up to 15 employees in total. In this specific context, the difference in size no longer justified a different approach to taking length of service into account when determining the indemnity.
The decision does not uphold the referring court’s request to set the maximum limit of the indemnity directly at 12 months’ pay, combining Article 9 of Legislative Decree no. 23/2015 with Article 18(5) of the Workers’ Statute and creating, thereby, a new provision rather than a remedy already provided for in the legal system . The Court therefore intervenes in a more limited manner, with a ruling that is purely ablative: the minimum indemnity of 2.5 months’ salary remains unchanged, whilst the maximum indemnity is extended, reaching up to 10 months’ salary (for employees with more than 10 years’ service) or 14 months’ salary (for employees with more than 20 years’ service), and is decided at the judge’s discretion , according to the criteria set out in Article 8 of Law no. 604/1966.
As regards the rationale, the Court takes as its starting point the “shift in perspective” brought about by its previous Judgment no. 118/2025: following the removal of the six-month salary cap, employees employed from 7 March 2015 onwards by employers below the threshold (i.e. with up to 15 employees in total) enjoy a generally higher level of compensation protection (ranging from 3 to 18 months’ salary) compared with those employed before that date. The justification for this difference in treatment, previously based on the aim of facilitating entry into the labour market, has thus lost much of its basis, not least in view of the greater difficulty older employees face in finding new employment.
To understand the scope of the ruling, it is important to bear in mind the different arrangements currently in place regarding the date of recruitment and the size of the employer.
For employees employed from 7 March 2015 by employers below the threshold, Article 9 of Legislative Decree no. 23/2015 applies. Judgment no. 118/2025 had already removed the maximum limit of 6 months’ pay for this category: in the cases referred to in Article 3(1) of Legislative Decree no. 23/2015, the indemnity may therefore range from 3 to 18 months’ pay, in accordance with the halving of the standard range (from 6 to 36 months’ pay).
The situation is different for companies above the threshold. For existing staff, Article 18 of the Workers’ Statute applies , under a system that distinguishes between cases of reinstatement and cases where protection is provided solely in the form of indemnity, the latter being subject to the limits laid down by law. For new recruits, however, Legislative Decree no. 23/2015 applies: in cases of indemnity provided for under Article 3, such amount ranges from 6 to 36 months’ salary, without prejudice to specific cases of reinstatement.
The ruling at hand, therefore, reduces a significant asymmetry amongst long-serving employees in companies above and below the threshold. It does not, however, eliminate the fragmentation of the system: the applicable regime continues to depend on the date of recruitment, the size of the company and the nature of the fault underlying the dismissal . A comprehensive reorganisation of the protection measures would be highly desirable.
Angelo Zambelli
angelo.zambelli@zambellipartners.com
Phone +39 02 02030830
Key Action Points for Human Resources and In-house Counsel
Practical Points
- The Constitutional Court has once again ruled on the system of safeguards against unlawful dismissal, eliminating – through Judgment no. 174/2026, filed on 22 October 2026 – a disparity in treatment affecting employees hired before 7 March 2015 by small companies with up to 15 employees in total;
- the minimum indemnity of 2.5 months’ salary remains unchanged, whilst the maximum indemnity is extended, reaching up to 10 months’ salary (for employees with more than 10 years’ service) or 14 months’ salary (for employees with more than 20 years’ service), and is decided at the judge’s discretion, according to the criteria set out in Article 8 of Law no. 604/1966.