international employment law firm alliance L&E Global
United Kingdom

Dismissal: involvement of HR in decision to dismiss does not automatically render decision unfair

In Shing v University of the Arts London [2026] EAT 154, a senior lecturer was summarily dismissed following an inappropriate relationship with a student. He argued that the dismissal was unfair because HR had become involved in the decision‑making process, relying on a case which had cautioned against HR involvement in questions of culpability.

The EAT rejected the appeal. It said that HR involvement in a disciplinary decision would not automatically make a dismissal unfair. The important question is whether HR, or anyone else outside the proper process, has placed undue pressure on the decision‑maker, and whether that has happened will depend on the particular facts.

Significantly, the EAT confirmed that there was no reason why HR should not, in an appropriate case, advise on the application of misconduct or serious misconduct. The EAT also highlighted that HR has a legitimate role in helping an organisation achieve consistency between disciplinary decisions. Here, HR had not improperly influenced Professor Crow, the decision‑maker. HR drafted the dismissal letter only after he had decided to dismiss; it did not alter an investigation report or exert undue pressure, and he had made his own decision to dismiss.

 

Key Action Points for Human Resources and In‑house Counsel

This case endorses the practical reality of many HR teams when dealing with employee misconduct. It is reassuring that HR does not have to limit its involvement in disciplinary cases to purely procedural matters but may provide appropriate advice, including to help ensure consistency of approach. The key is that the ultimate decision should remain with the appointed decision‑maker. Employers should therefore ensure that HR’s role is clearly documented and that advice does not cross the line into exerting undue pressure or effectively making the decision on the manager’s behalf.

Contact

Did you like what you read?

And do you need more information about this subject or can we assist you in a legal matter?