Neurodiversity in recruitment: assessing stress and making adjustments
In Bryce v Coventry City Council, a candidate with an autism spectrum disorder and dyslexia unsuccessfully applied for a team manager role. The Council provided questions in advance, offered the final interview slot and sought to follow National Autistic Society guidance. Mr Bryce claimed failure to make reasonable adjustments, including failure to offer closed questions only, and that he suffered unfavourable treatment arising from disability, which he said included stress in new situations such as interviews. The Employment Tribunal dismissed both claims. It accepted an interviewer’s view that he had not appeared particularly stressed and seemed confident, partly because he had requested adjustments and declined to share his screen when asked.
The EAT upheld the stress‑related appeal. The Tribunal had adopted the interviewer’s impressions without considering whether someone with the candidate’s disabilities would manifest stress like a neurotypical person. The interviewer was not an expert on those conditions. Alternatively, if the Tribunal meant stress had not materially affected the interview, its reasons were inadequate.
Although the EAT did not find that discrimination had occurred, it did conclude that the unfavourable treatment claim should be reheard by a new Tribunal. However, the reasonable adjustments appeal failed. Rewording questions could reduce disadvantage under time pressure, but the questions already met the specialist guidance. Restricting answers to yes or no was not reasonable where this would prevent effective assessment of relevant skills.
Key Action Points for Human Resources and In‑house Counsel
Careful planning and adjustments help support neurodivergent candidates during a recruitment process and reduce legal risk. However, employers should avoid equating apparent confidence with an absence of disability‑related stress. Their duty is not necessarily limited to requested adjustments: consider measures that reasonably address known disadvantage while preserving effective assessment.
Discuss individual barriers and adjustments with candidates, and record the support provided and reasons for selection decisions.