international employment law firm alliance L&E Global
Germany

No equivalent status ‘between the lines’: a severe disability or equivalent status must be clearly communicated by an applicant

Applicants who wish to rely on their severe disability or equivalent status during the recruitment process need to inform the employer of this in a sufficiently clear manner. The Baden‑Württemberg Regional Labour Court has clarified that employers are not required to infer equivalent status on the basis of information that is subtle or scattered throughout the application documents.

This ruling is particularly relevant to digital application processes. Information in a CV must be presented and worded in such a way that the employer can clearly identify the severe disability or equivalent status. A stated degree of disability of 40 does not, by itself, tell the employer that the applicant has been granted equivalent status. Furthermore, attached documents might not be sufficient if the relevant status is not made sufficiently clear.

 

Background

The claimant had a degree of disability of 40 and had held status equivalent to that of a severely disabled person in accordance with Section 2(3) of the German Social Code (Book IX) (“SGB IX”) since 2024. In February 2025, he applied for two positions with the defendant via an online application portal. In his CV, under the heading ‘Internship’, he mentioned a work interruption due to illness from 1998 to 1999 following sudden hearing loss and subsequent balance problems. He stated a degree of disability of 40 under the same heading. Under ‘Further documents’, he also uploaded the decision granting equivalent status from the Federal Employment Agency.

After his applications had not been included on the shortlist, the claimant demanded compensation of at least 15,000 euros. He claimed that he had been disadvantaged because of his equivalent status. The defendant contended that it had not been sufficiently aware of the claimant’s equivalent status. The reference to a degree of disability of 40 had been inconspicuously placed in the CV and did not allow any conclusions to be drawn regarding existing equivalent status.

The Labour Court dismissed the claim. The Baden‑Württemberg Regional Labour Court upheld this decision and dismissed the appeal. However, it allowed a further appeal to the Federal Labour Court on points of law due to the significance of the case as a matter of principle.

 

Key Issues

The Regional Labour Court stated that, in principle, a failure by the employer to comply with procedural and support obligations in favour of people with severe disabilities or those treated as such may result in a presumption of discrimination on the grounds of disability under Section 22 of the German General Act on Equal Treatment (“AGG”), which can in turn lead to compensation claims by the rejected applicant. The defendant had not placed an employment order with the employment agency for the available jobs in question. However, following the court’s overall evaluation of the specific case, this was not decisive because the defendant neither knew nor was required to know that the claimant had equivalent status.

The key factor was that the claimant had not made his equivalent status sufficiently clear in his application documents. The CV simply stated a degree of disability of 40. From this, the employer was not required to conclude that the applicant had a severe disability or that the applicant was to be treated as a person with a severe disability. Furthermore, the mention was placed under the details listed under the heading ‘Internship’. It was therefore not clear that the information described the applicant’s current status nor, in the court’s view, was it sufficiently highlighted.

Even the additional document granting equivalent status that was uploaded as part of the application documents did not change the situation. In the view of the Regional Labour Court, applicants cannot assume that the employer will take note of every additional file submitted. In the specific case, the file name itself also failed to make sufficiently clear that the applicant had equivalent status to a severely disabled person. It is therefore essential that the characteristic in question is communicated in such a way that it is clearly recognisable to the employer.

 

“Practical Point”

  • For employers, the decision provides greater clarity when reviewing application documents. A severe disability or equivalent status must be communicated in a sufficiently clear and transparent manner. Employers are not required to interpret or infer it themselves on the basis of inconspicuous or scattered information.
  • In particular, merely stating a degree of disability of less than 50 does not require employers to assume that the applicant has been granted equivalent status to a severely disabled person. Moreover, employers are not required to infer severe disability or equivalent status from supplementary documents that are not clearly identifiable or that have been uploaded without any relevant indication.
  • As soon as severe disability or equivalent status is sufficiently evident, the rest of the recruitment process should be adapted to ensure compliance with the relevant legal requirements and mitigate the risk of compensation claims in case of a rejection of the application.

 

Authors: Verena Braeckeler‑Kogel, MAES (Basel) and Meike Christine Rehner

 

Verena Braeckeler‑Kogel, MAES (Basel)

braeckeler@pwwl.de

+49 (0) 211 52 87 45-0

Meike Christine Rehner

rehner@pwwl.de

+49 (0) 89 215 39 28-0

Contact

Did you like what you read?

And do you need more information about this subject or can we assist you in a legal matter?