international employment law firm alliance L&E Global
Germany

Parental leave despite cessation of own childcare: in principle, employees are bound by their request

The Federal Labour Court has ruled that an employee’s move out of the household previously shared with the child’s mother and their child generally does not prevent the employee from taking parental leave that had previously been requested from his employer. If the employee does not intend to take parental leave any more, this is subject to the statutory conditions governing its early termination.

If an employee does not wish to take parental leave that has already been requested, or wishes to terminate it early, this is governed by Section 16(3) of the Federal Parental Allowance and Parental Leave Act (“BEEG”). In principle, the employer’s consent is required for this. In the case of the birth of a further child or in cases of particular hardship, the employer may only refuse the early termination in writing within four weeks on urgent operational grounds.

According to the Federal Labour Court, the mere fact that an employee is no longer entitled to parental allowance because they do not live with their child any more does not in itself constitute a case of particular hardship. The ruling thus provides greater planning certainty for employers who have already made decisions regarding staffing on the basis of requests for parental leave.

 

Background

The claimant had been employed by the defendant since 2011 and requested parental leave for the period from 23 May 2024 to 23 May 2025. Before his parental leave began, he separated from the mother of his child and moved out of their shared home. The child remained with the mother. The claimant then demanded that he be allowed to continue working, as, in his view, the conditions for parental leave were no longer fulfilled. The defendant refused because the company had already taken on a temporary replacement for the requested period of parental leave.

By filing the claim, the claimant sought a declaration that his parental leave had not commenced. The Düsseldorf Regional Labour Court granted his application. The defendant’s appeal on points of law was successful before the Federal Labour Court. In the opinion of the Federal Labour Court, the claimant was on parental leave despite having moved out of the shared household.

 

Key Issues

The Federal Labour Court focused on the binding effect of a request for parental leave. The subsequent loss of a condition for parental leave does not automatically mean that parental leave that had previously been requested is cancelled or does not begin. Section 16(4) of the BEEG only contains an explicit special provision for the event that the child in need of care dies.

Aside from this, early termination of parental leave is governed by Section 16(3) of the BEEG. According to the ruling, this provision also applies in cases where the employee does not wish to take the requested parental leave at all. In this particular case, the employer had not consented to the parental leave not commencing. Furthermore, the claimant had not sought replacement of such consent through the courts.

The court also found that the claimant had not established particular hardship. The fact that the claimant is no longer entitled to parental allowance because he has moved out of the shared household is not reason enough in itself. In particular, the claimant had not argued that he was no longer able to provide for himself or to provide adequate maintenance for his child.

 

“Practical Point”

  • Employers can generally base their staff planning on a valid request for parental leave. A subsequent change in family circumstances does not automatically mean that parental leave is cancelled or does not commence.
  • If an employee decides not to take parental leave that has already been requested, or to terminate it early, employers should consider whether to agree to the change or whether the specific conditions set out in Section 16(3), second sentence, of the BEEG apply.
  • If an employee claims that their circumstances constitute a case of particular hardship, the specific personal and financial circumstances put forward should be carefully checked and the relevant time limits set out in Section 16(3) of the BEEG should be observed.
  • According to the ruling, the loss of entitlement to parental allowance does not in itself constitute a case of particular hardship.

 

Authors: Verena Braeckeler‑Kogel, MAES (Basel) and Meike Christine Rehner

 

Verena Braeckeler‑Kogel, MAES (Basel)

braeckeler@pwwl.de

+49 (0) 211 52 87 45-0

Meike Christine Rehner

rehner@pwwl.de

+49 (0) 89 215 39 28-0

Contact

Did you like what you read?

And do you need more information about this subject or can we assist you in a legal matter?